doom3 mod

[seanstar]

I was banned without uploading any files and without warning...thats not logical.

you can find quak1arena on terminus and thats a quake3 to quake1 mod...those textures and models are ported from quake3...whats the difference?

Unbans!
Then again, my understanding is that Seanstar is Conner and Quakeworld.nu got in a bit of trouble over some models from some models from mod I can't recall but the author was Talbun.

rook hosted the bmodels your talking about in his pak file, it wouldnt surprise me if those bmodels are still being hosted by him...he gave no credit to tabun and phoenix like i did...instead he thanks me by coming on my thread with models and texture so far beyond this game thats its not even slightly comparable and says

edit so that its easy for some people to understand but really it was only meant for one.

Seanster is big on taking media from other games, globbing slappy textures to them, and meshing it together like a bunch of scrap pieces of soap to made a new bar of blucky-poo. It's cool to be creative when you're young, so have fun while it lasts.

what do you know? who are you to say anything to me about models and textures?

lets see your quality content before you start bashing mine.

[bFeared]

I was banned without uploading any files and without warning...thats not logical.

you can find quak1arena on terminus and thats a quake3 to quake1 mod...those textures and models are ported from quake3...whats the difference?


rook hosted the bmodels your talking about in his pak file, it wouldnt surprise me if those bmodels are still being hosted by him...he gave no credit to tabun and phoenix like i did...instead he thanks me by coming on my thread with models and texture so far beyond this game thats its not even slightly comparable and says

Seanster is big on taking media from other games, globbing slappy textures to them, and meshing it together like a bunch of scrap pieces of soap to made a new bar of blucky-poo

what do you know? who are you to say anything to me about models and textures?

lets see your quality content before you start bashing mine.

The quote button is on the right side of the post, FYI.

[Skutarth]

I was banned without uploading any files and without warning...thats not logical.

I agree. I was just saying that any links you post should be removed, not that you should be banned.

you can find quak1arena on terminus and thats a quake3 to quake1 mod...those textures and models are ported from quake3...whats the difference?

That's funny. I don't recall any textures or models from Quake 3 used in Quake 1 Arena. In fact, I hardly remember any new content at all, other than QC changes. Perhaps the "talk bubble" from when people are typing, but even that could easily have been reproduced well enough to be indistinguishable from the original.

what do you know? who are you to say anything to me about models and textures?

lets see your quality content before you start bashing mine.

I contributed art to Last Man Standing for Doom 3 before Calimer (Michael Tomaino) decided to be a complete douchebag and not credit me for anything. I ended up stooping down to legal threats for him to remove my content from the last version they released. Sad, considering he had almost nothing to do with Last Man Standing's creation or maintenance other than taking credit for almost everything.

It's obvious that what R00k said was correct. Most of the time you have even posted the screenshot you used to patchwork the skin from. Every single one of your non-diffuse textures (specular, bump, and normal maps) have been created solely by applying Photoshop filters to the diffuse texture (and a bump map to normal map generator). It's clear as day that it's what you do. Bump maps aren't just grayscale versions of the texture, dipshit. They are supposed to actually contain meaningful normal data for light bouncing calculations. Quit acting like you're hot shit, you fucking amateur.

[Grim Warlock]

I've just learned never to post a link on these forums again!

[R00k]

what do you know? Who are you to say anything to me about models and textures? Lets see your quality content before you start bashing mine.

it was just my opinion.

[foq]

Try to post something cool in a place where people who might appriciate it hang out, and get beat half to death, then have salt and vinegar poured all over you...

[Grim Warlock]

Try to post something cool in a place where people who might appriciate it hang out, and get beat half to death, then have salt and vinegar poured all over you...

Cool story, troll.

[foq]

Cool story, troll.

Wasn't trolling.

[Grim Warlock]

Damn, fucking f0qers.

[Baker]

I was banned without uploading any files and without warning...thats not logical.

It wasn't logical at all and made no sense. I blame "other people" TM.

I really can't recall my logic at the time.

Comically bad forum admining.

[Grim Warlock]

It wasn't logical at all and made no sense. I blame "other people" TM.

I really can't recall my logic at the time.

Comically bad forum admining.

At least this forum's better than Quake Live.

[Baker]

Either way, that was a "admin-fail" on my part.

It didn't really make any sense, and I can't even remember my reasoning.

[Solecord]

brb. banning Baker.

[Solecord]

I don't see a problem with posting a video from Youtube here. But if the models are protected from other games and you're incorporating them without proper permission, please keep links to the actual files off the forums. Thanks!

(if others have done this and we've let it slide, please us the Report feature of the forums to notify an admin. The Report link is below a user's information on the left side of their post.)

[Skutarth]

it was just my opinion.

It was an opinion I happen to agree with.

It wasn't logical at all and made no sense. I blame "other people" TM.

I really can't recall my logic at the time.

Comically bad forum admining.

You did it right after I pointed out that any download links should be removed because they would infringe copyright. You should read more on Wikipedia than just the page on Fair Use. Perhaps reading about Derivative Work would help you out. And don't read too closely into the categories looked into in Fair Use cases. All of them are considered, not just one, and none of them are guaranteed defenses.

Consider that:
1. He has never claimed his work to be for the purpose of parody or education (in fact, he acts like he's a fucking professional).
2. The entirety of his work involves copying and pasting portions of Doom 3 screenshots and ripped texture files. That is conducive to unprotected derivative work, since no original expression is involved. Since he does not own Doom 3, but a license for it (if he even has a legal license), he doesn't have the right to distribute such derivative work.